i noticed it several times that the forwards of my opponent are way ahead against my last defenders and the thing is, no OFF SIDE ruling. the effect is so damaging cause once they received the ball they quickly strike and then BANG, goal.

one more thing, the tactics option seems not consistent..there was a few times when i chose a super defensive with normal strategy, instead of defending my gate all my players seems eager to score a goal in the other side or some would just stand still though under attack.

theres still a lot more crazy annoying stuff i observed during the games which is contrary to the settings i made, i hope all these things will be corrected and improved soon cause even that said 11x11 is still the best from the rest...

The 2-D animation has nothing to do with your settings. The game is already simulated, when you see the 2-D action. It is just a little gimmick.

so how could we be managers if we cant see the effect of our settings..we cant rely on a permanent settings cause i notice its not consistent..im a level 3 player and got beaten by a level 1 in his very first game, its just crazy. 87 average skill was destroyed by 65 averaged skill newbie with same 100% stamina. the result was 3:0 with 9 shot attempts against my team with 0 attempt shots..

are the winners randomly chosen too? can anyone explain this to me..thanks.

good point!!
and why not the 2d animation be what actually happened in the game??!! so that we managers could evaluate our players & tactics.

I wanted to ask something,is the stats in the 2d is real or just a part of the gimmik?
keem

Aside from the numbers, the only differences are the scheme and tactics, redmax is a level 5 player with superior players but i won our game, if you notice the stats redmax is supposed to be unbeatable against my level 4 team..

kent5: Redmax_DE:
1099 power bases on the roster 1306
99.9 The average skill of best 11 players 118.7
85.9 Average skill of the players on the field 119.1
4-3-3 scheme 4-4-2
Super Attacker (100%) Tactics protective (36%)
no Pressing no
Counter-attacking Strategy Counter-attacking
long Passes long

my point is, i think the stats are also gimmicks..

Stats are correct since they are determined at the start of the kick off. However, whether are are displayed correct in the 2D is a question. As you might have noticed, the stats for yellow card doesn't really represent the cards given to your team. I think some components that might it up consist of shots off target.

in my opinion, the 2D is gimmick as well but the 2D report (stat) is actually correct (as far as i notice).

when level 5 player lose against lower lever player, it's not impossible, there are many factor for this case. Could be the scheme, stamina (don't forget the power also), moral, friendly or cup match (it sure make the different, maybe the prestige), and many more...
correct me if i'm wrong.